Tally Man is a skilled sharpshooter for hire. On the night of Scarecrow's chemical attack on Pauli's Diner, a former Arkham City inmate mentioned how he had lost all of the money he had been given as a result of Protocol 10, and that one of his six debtors had even threatened to send Tally Man after him.

It was also rumoured that Tally Man was able to, from Blackgate Prison, shoot out a target's kneecaps in Arkham Asylum.